When guitar players talk about “the good old days,” they’re often referring to the golden era of Fender instruments – those magical decades when Leo Fender and his team were creating what would become the blueprint for modern electric guitars. The American Vintage II series stands as Fender’s most faithful tribute to this legacy, meticulously recreating iconic models with a commitment to historical accuracy that borders on obsession.

The newest additions to this prestigious lineup are the American Vintage II 1965 Stratocaster and the Limited Edition American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster – represent two pivotal moments in Fender’s evolution. The ’65 Strat captures the instrument during a transitional period as CBS took ownership of the company, while the ’51 Tele commemorates the very first production year of what would become the world’s first commercially successful solid-body electric guitar.

What follows is our comprehensive breakdown of these remarkable time capsules – their historical significance, build characteristics, tonal qualities, and how they compare to each other.

Historical Context: Two Defining Moments

The 1965 Stratocaster: Transition and Evolution

1965 marks a watershed moment in Fender history, the year Leo Fender sold his company to CBS. This transition period brought subtle yet meaningful changes to the iconic Stratocaster. The American Vintage II 1965 Stratocaster faithfully recreates these historical details, from the thicker “transition” logo that replaced the earlier “spaghetti” headstock logo to the round-laminated rosewood fingerboard with pearloid inlays instead of clay dots.

Perhaps most significant was the introduction of “gray bottom” pickups, which began appearing in 1965 Stratocasters. These pickups are generally considered warmer and fuller-sounding than their predecessors, helping define the tone that powered much of the rock music during this era. The American Vintage II reissue meticulously recreates these pickups to capture that authentic mid-60s Stratocaster voice.

The 1951 Telecaster: The Blueprint That Changed Everything

If the 1965 Stratocaster represents evolution, the 1951 Telecaster stands for genesis. Originally launched as the Broadcaster before a trademark dispute with Gretsch forced a name change, the Telecaster of 1951 was groundbreaking and the world’s first commercially successful solid-body electric guitar. Its simple, utilitarian design would influence virtually every electric guitar that followed.

Key design elements of the original 1951 Telecaster included an ash body, a substantial “U”-shaped one-piece maple neck, and a single-ply black phenolic pickguard. The Limited Edition American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster faithfully recreates these features, along with period-correct Pure Vintage ’51 Single-Coil pickups that deliver the bright, twangy tone that made the Telecaster famous.

What makes this release particularly special is the “Prototype White” finish option, inspired by the white paint Leo Fender used on some of his earliest prototypes, offering a unique aesthetic connection to the very birth of the electric guitar as we know it.

Watch: Fender’s American Vintage II Series by Joshua Ray G

Get an exclusive behind-the-scenes look at the American Vintage II series straight from Fender Studios! In this video, guitarist Joshua Ray G joins Fender’s Alan Abasi to showcase the stunning 1965 Stratocaster and limited edition 1951 Telecaster in Prototype White that we’ve detailed in this article.

Joshua puts the 1965 Strat through its paces with mesmerizing demonstrations that highlight the guitar’s incredible clarity and versatility across multiple playing styles. You’ll hear firsthand impressions after hours of playing and see close-up details of the period-correct features that make these instruments so special – from the distinctive “transition” logo to the unique gray-bottom pickups that define the ’65 Strat’s warm tone.

The video also offers a glimpse of the breathtaking finish options available across the American Vintage II lineup, including the rarely-seen Prototype White Telecaster that pays homage to Leo Fender’s earliest experimental instruments. For any vintage guitar enthusiast, this four-minute walkthrough provides valuable insights into the meticulous craftsmanship that makes these reissues so faithful to their historical counterparts.

Technical Specifications: A Side-by-Side Comparison

To truly understand the differences between these two iconic models, let’s examine their specifications in detail:

Sound Quality: Two Distinct Voices

The 1965 Stratocaster: Warm Versatility

The American Vintage II 1965 Stratocaster’s voice is defined by its Pure Vintage ’65 Gray-Bottom pickups. These pickups deliver a warmer, fuller tone than earlier Stratocaster models, with a richness in the midrange that works beautifully for blues and rock. The alder body contributes to this tonal profile with its balanced frequency response and robust low-end.

The five-way pickup selector offers considerable tonal versatility:

• Position 1 (Bridge): Bright and cutting with plenty of bite
• Position 2 (Bridge + Middle): The classic “quack” that’s perfect for funk and country
• Position 3 (Middle): A balanced, rounded tone that sits perfectly in a mix
• Position 4 (Middle + Neck): A hollow, out-of-phase sound ideal for clean playing
• Position 5 (Neck): Warm and full-bodied, perfect for melodic lines and solos

The synchronized tremolo system provides expressive vibrato options, from subtle shimmer to dramatic dives, making the ’65 Strat a truly versatile instrument capable of handling virtually any genre of music.

The 1951 Telecaster: Twang and Clarity

The Limited Edition American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster offers a completely different tonal palette. Its Pure Vintage ’51 Single-Coil pickups deliver the bright, twangy sound that defined early country and rock and roll. The ash body enhances this brightness with clear, articulate highs and defined lows.

The three-way pickup selector provides:

• Position 1 (Bridge): The quintessential Telecaster twang – bright, cutting, and assertive
• Position 2 (Bridge + Neck): A balanced blend that retains clarity while adding warmth
• Position 3 (Neck): Rich and full without being muddy, perfect for jazz and blues

The fixed bridge with brass barrel saddles contributes to the guitar’s substantial sustain and bright attack, creating the signature Telecaster sound that has proven remarkably versatile across musical genres for over seven decades.

Playability and Feel: Vintage Authenticity

The 1965 Stratocaster: Comfortable Familiarity

The 1965 “C”-shaped neck profile on the American Vintage II 1965 Stratocaster offers a comfortable playing experience that accommodates a wide range of playing styles. The profile is substantial without being overly chunky, allowing for easy chord work and single-note runs alike.

The 7.25″ fingerboard radius is notably more curved than modern guitars, providing an authentic vintage feel that many players find better suits chord playing, especially with the thumb wrapped around the neck. Combined with the vintage tall frets, this radius creates a distinctly vintage playing experience that remains comfortable for many techniques.

The contoured body of the Stratocaster – a revolutionary design feature when introduced in 1954 – provides excellent ergonomics, making the guitar comfortable for extended playing sessions. The synchronized tremolo allows for expressive pitch manipulation, from subtle vibrato to dramatic dive-bombs.

The 1951 Telecaster: Substantial Vintage Character

The 1951 Telecaster offers a markedly different playing experience with its 1951 “U”-shaped neck profile. This neck is substantially thicker than the Stratocaster’s, providing a fuller grip that many players describe as “massive” or “chunky.” While it might require adjustment for players accustomed to modern, thinner neck profiles, many guitarists find this substantial feel provides excellent stability and tonal benefits.

Like the Stratocaster, the Telecaster features a 7.25″ fingerboard radius and vintage tall frets, maintaining that authentic vintage feel. The slab body design is simpler than the Stratocaster’s contoured body, reflecting the utilitarian origins of the instrument.

The fixed bridge provides excellent tuning stability and sustain, with no need to worry about tremolo setup or maintenance. This straightforward design philosophy extends to the control layout, with a simple volume and tone control arrangement that keeps the focus on playing rather than tweaking.

Build Quality and Aesthetics: Period-Correct Details

Both guitars demonstrate Fender’s commitment to historical accuracy, featuring period-correct finishes, hardware, and design details.

The American Vintage II 1965 Stratocaster is available in historically accurate color options such as:

• Candy Apple Red
• Shoreline Gold
• Sonic Blue

Each finish is applied using a gloss nitrocellulose lacquer over a thin polyurethane basecoat, consistent with the finishing methods used on mid-’60s Fender guitars. The “transition” logo on the headstock and the pearloid dot inlays on the rosewood fingerboard are meticulously recreated to match original ’65 specifications.

The Limited Edition American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster in Prototype White offers a unique aesthetic inspired by Leo Fender’s earliest prototypes. This historically significant finish provides a distinctive look that stands apart from the more common Butterscotch Blonde finish typically associated with vintage Telecasters. The black phenolic pickguard and chrome hardware complete the streamlined, utilitarian aesthetic that made the Telecaster such a revolutionary instrument.

Value Proposition: Investment in Craftsmanship

At $2,299.99 for the American Vintage II 1965 Stratocaster and $2,449.99 for the Limited Edition American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster, these instruments represent a significant investment. However, when considered in the context of what’s being offered – meticulously researched reissues of historically significant instruments built with premium materials and craftsmanship – the value proposition becomes clear.

For players seeking the authentic vintage Fender experience without the potential maintenance issues and astronomical prices of actual vintage instruments, the American Vintage II series offers a compelling alternative. The attention to detail in replicating period-correct specifications results in instruments that not only look and feel like their historical counterparts but sound remarkably authentic as well.

Who Are These Guitars For?

The American Vintage II 1965 Stratocaster will appeal to players who:

• Seek the warmer, fuller tone characteristic of CBS-era Stratocasters
• Prefer a comfortable “C”-shaped neck profile
• Value tonal versatility and expressive vibrato options
• Have an affinity for classic rock, blues, funk, and pop sounds
• Appreciate the historical significance of the transitional 1965 period

The Limited Edition American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster will resonate with players who:

• Desire the bright, twangy tone that defined early country and rock and roll
• Enjoy a substantial “U”-shaped neck profile
• Prefer simplicity and straightforward design
• Gravitate toward country, rockabilly, blues, and early rock sounds
• Value the historical importance of the first production Telecaster
• Appreciate the unique aesthetic of the Prototype White finish

Final Verdict: Two Distinct Pathways to Vintage Authenticity

The American Vintage II 1965 Stratocaster and the Limited Edition American Vintage II 1951 Telecaster both achieve what they set out to do – provide authentic vintage Fender experiences with meticulous attention to historical accuracy. Rather than competing with each other, they represent two distinct approaches to electric guitar design that have shaped music for over seven decades.

The 1965 Stratocaster captures a moment of transition in Fender’s history, offering the warmer tone and refined aesthetics that characterized the beginning of the CBS era. The 1951 Telecaster, by contrast, represents the pure, foundational design that started it all – the blueprint that would influence virtually every solid-body electric guitar that followed.

For the vintage enthusiast, the dedicated Fender aficionado, or simply the player who appreciates exceptional craftsmanship and authentic tone, both guitars offer remarkable experiences that connect directly to pivotal moments in the journey of the electric guitar. Whether you’re drawn to the versatile warmth of the ’65 Strat or the fundamental twang of the ’51 Tele, these instruments provide a genuine connection to Fender’s rich heritage and the sounds that have defined generations of music.

So, which one would peaks your interest, if any? Leave your feedback in the comments below.

👉 Check out more deals and gear reviews on the Get My Guitar Blog.

👉 Join our guitarist community to share your finds and discuss all things guitar!