We thought we knew what would happen when we tossed that question into the X universe: “What are the greatest acoustic guitar intros of all time?” Maybe “Stairway to Heaven” would cruise to victory, or perhaps “Blackbird” would flutter to the top. Boy, were we wrong.

After watching our post rack up 44K+ views and spark heated debates in the comments, the results are in—and they’re absolutely wild. Our X guitar community has spoken, and their choice for the ultimate acoustic intro champion isn’t what anyone saw coming.

The Shocking Winner That Left Everyone Stunned

Hold onto your picks, folks. The undisputed champion, absolutely demolishing the competition with more than triple the votes of any other contender, is Heart’s “Crazy on You.” Yes, you read that right. Nancy Wilson’s intricate fingerpicked masterpiece didn’t just win—it obliterated the field like a Marshall stack cranked to 11.

This wasn’t even close. While legendary tracks battled tooth and nail for second place, “Crazy on You” was off in its own stratosphere, proving that sometimes the most obvious choice isn’t always the right one. Nancy Wilson’s cascading arpeggios and that hauntingly beautiful progression clearly struck a chord (pun intended) with guitarists who know greatness when they hear it.

The Greatest Acoustic Guitar Intros – The Complete Rankings

Here’s how the dust settled after our community cast their votes:

The three-way tie for second place tells its own story. While “Stairway” showed up as expected, sharing the silver medal with Yes’s progressive masterpiece “Roundabout” and Pink Floyd’s melancholy beauty “Wish You Were Here” shows our community appreciates complexity and atmosphere over pure popularity.

Breaking Down the Champions

The Undisputed King: “Crazy on You” by Heart

Nancy Wilson crafted something truly special here. That opening fingerpicked sequence isn’t just pretty—it’s a technical showcase wrapped in pure passion and feel. The way she weaves between bass notes and treble flourishes creates this hypnotic pull that grabs you from the first note. It’s the kind of intro that makes bedroom guitarists everywhere frantically reach for their instruments, thinking “I need to learn this right now.”

What makes this intro legendary isn’t just the technique—though Nancy’s fingerpicking chops are undeniable—it’s how perfectly it sets up the entire song. Those opening measures paint a picture before Ann Wilson even opens her mouth.

The Silver Medal Slugfest

Stairway to Heaven – Led Zeppelin Jimmy Page’s gentle opening on his double-neck Gibson is probably the most recognized acoustic intro in rock history. That Am-C-D-F-G progression has been strummed in guitar shops across the globe so often that some stores have banned it entirely. The beauty lies in its simplicity—Page proves that sometimes the most profound statements come from the most basic building blocks.

Roundabout – Yes Steve Howe’s Spanish classical guitar opening to “Roundabout” showcases a completely different approach. Those rapid-fire arpeggios and that distinctive nylon-string tone transport you somewhere completely different before the band crashes in with full prog-rock fury. It’s like a miniature classical concert that happens to lead into one of the most infectious bass lines ever recorded.

Wish You Were Here – Pink Floyd David Gilmour’s 12-string opening is pure atmosphere. Those shimmering, slightly detuned chords create this wistful, nostalgic mood that perfectly captures the song’s theme of absence and longing. It’s not technically flashy, but it’s devastatingly effective at creating a mood. Sometimes the most powerful guitar work happens in the spaces between the notes.

The Deep Cuts That Impressed Our Community

What really caught our attention wasn’t just the winners—it was the incredible diversity in the single-vote category. Songs like “La Villa Strangiato” by Rush, “Spanish Caravan” by The Doors, and “Horizons” by Steve Hackett show that our community digs deep into catalog cuts and prog-rock treasures.

“Classical Gas” by Mason Williams making the list proves that instrumental pieces still have their place in the pantheon of great acoustic intros. And seeing “Chop Suey!” by System of a Down sneak in there? That’s exactly the kind of curveball that makes these community polls so entertaining.

What the Comments Revealed

Our community didn’t just vote—they passionately defended their choices. Here are some of the most memorable takes from the comment section:

“Nancy Wilson doesn’t get nearly enough credit for her acoustic work. That intro is a masterclass in fingerstyle technique.”

“How is ‘Dust in the Wind’ not higher? That picking pattern is literally the first thing every acoustic player learns!”

“Stairway is great, but it’s been done to death. Time to appreciate some deeper cuts.”

The debates got heated, with prog-rock fans championing the technical complexity of their favorites while classic rock purists argued for the timeless appeal of simpler compositions. One comment perfectly summed up the divide:

“There’s a difference between the most technically impressive and the most legendary. Sometimes a simple chord progression hits harder than all the fancy fingerpicking in the world.”

Led Zeppelin’s Surprising Dominance

While Heart took the crown, Led Zeppelin quietly dominated the rankings with three separate entries: “Stairway to Heaven,” “Over The Hills And Far Away,” and “Ramble On.” This speaks to Jimmy Page’s incredible versatility as an acoustic player. Whether he was crafting gentle folk-inspired passages or driving Celtic-influenced rhythms, Page understood how to make the acoustic guitar serve the song rather than just showing off his chops.

“Over The Hills And Far Away” particularly impressed voters with its intricate DADGAD tuning work, proving that Page was experimenting with alternate tunings long before it became trendy in modern indie circles.

The 1970s Golden Age Effect

Looking at the results, there’s a clear pattern: the 1970s absolutely dominated this list. From Heart to Led Zeppelin to Pink Floyd to Yes, the decade that gave us arena rock also perfected the art of the acoustic intro. This wasn’t accidental—the era’s recording technology finally allowed acoustic guitars to be captured with the warmth and detail they deserved, while radio was hungry for songs that could shift dynamics and keep listeners engaged.

The production values of that era, particularly the spacious reverbs and careful mic placement, helped these intros breathe in ways that earlier recordings couldn’t achieve. When you hear the opening of “Wish You Were Here” or “Crazy on You,” you’re not just hearing great playing—you’re hearing great recording.

Modern Perspective: Why These Intros Still Matter in 2025

In an age of bedroom producers and laptop recording, these acoustic intros remind us of something important: sometimes the most powerful musical moments come from a single person, a single guitar, and a great idea. No plugins, no samples, no digital wizardry—just wood, strings, and skill.

These songs have survived format changes from vinyl to streaming, proving that great acoustic guitar work transcends technology. While today’s players might be influenced by YouTube tutorials and Instagram clips, the fundamental appeal of a perfectly crafted acoustic intro remains unchanged.

The Guitars Behind the Magic: Top 5 Intros and Their Instruments

Let’s talk about the gear that made these acoustic guitar intros legendary. Half the magic behind these songs comes from the guitars themselves—and here’s what our champions were actually playing when they created these timeless moments.

1. “Crazy on You” – Heart’s Nancy Wilson

Original Guitar: Guild Jumbo with particularly high action that was “hellish to play” Modern Alternative: Martin HD-35.

Nancy’s original recording was done on a Guild Jumbo that fought back with every note, but she now uses her Martin HD-35 Dreadnought as her main go-to acoustic. For players wanting to chase that “Crazy on You” tone today, the Martin signature model delivers similar warmth and projection with far better playability. Wilson designed it to be “Crosby, Stills & Nash-like, a three-piece back, dreadnought style” with “such a good, responsive tone”.

2. “Stairway to Heaven” – Led Zeppelin’s Jimmy Page

Original Guitar: 1960s Harmony Sovereign H1260 acoustic guitar Modern Alternative: Gibson J-45 Studio or Martin D-28

While Page’s Harmony guitar holds “significant value to him, as it was not only featured in Stairway to Heaven but also played a major role in the early years of Led Zeppelin”, modern players can achieve similar tonal qualities with a Gibson J-45 Studio for that woody, vintage character, or a Martin D-28 for slightly brighter projection that cuts through a mix.

3. “Roundabout” – Yes’s Steve Howe

Original Guitar: Martin 00-18, using it “for the first time on a Yes recording” Modern Alternative: Martin 00-18 or Taylor 812ce.

Howe’s “now famous Martin 00-18” created those crystalline arpeggios that open “Roundabout.” The Martin 00-18 Authentic 1937 reissue captures the vintage vibe, while a Taylor 812ce offers similar clarity with modern intonation and playability that’ll make those rapid-fire passages more forgiving.

4. “Wish You Were Here” – Pink Floyd’s David Gilmour

Original Guitar: 1971 Martin D12-28 12-string Modern Alternative: Martin D12-28 or Taylor 150ce 12-String

Gilmour wrote “Wish You Were Here” on his Martin D12-28, saying “I wrote that on a 12-string Martin. I bought it off a friend of mine in about ’72 or ’73, I guess… That riff dragged itself out of that guitar”. The current Martin D12-28 maintains that same shimmering 12-string character, while the Taylor 150e offers excellent electronics for live performance.

5. “Hotel California” – Eagles’ Don Felder

Original Guitar: Takamine 12-string with a DeArmond pickup Modern Alternative: Takamine P3D-12 or Martin D12E

Felder recorded the intro on “a Takamine 12-string with a DeArmond pickup. We miked the acoustic and put that in the center of the mix. Then we took the pickup’s output and ran it though an Echoplex and a Leslie”. The modern Takamine P3D-12 carries on that legacy with superior electronics, while the Martin D12X1AE offers that classic Martin 12-string jangle with modern pickup technology.

Techniques That Made These Intros Legendary

What separates these winners from the thousands of other acoustic intros out there? Several key elements appear consistently:

• Dynamic Contrast: The best intros create space for the full band to explode in later. “Crazy on You” and “Stairway” both build from intimate whispers to thunderous climaxes.
• Memorable Melodic Content: These aren’t just chord progressions—they’re hooks. You can hum Nancy Wilson’s fingerpicked melody or Gilmour’s 12-string arpeggios.
• Technical Innovation: Whether it’s alternate tunings, fingerpicking patterns, or harmonic choices, each winner brought something new to the table that influenced countless players who came after.

The Surprising Absence of Obvious Choices

Perhaps more interesting than what made the list is what didn’t. “Blackbird,” “Tears in Heaven,” and “More Than Words” — songs that dominated MTV Unplugged and acoustic compilation albums — barely registered with our community. This suggests that guitarists value complexity and innovation over mainstream popularity.

The absence of more modern entries also speaks to the lasting power of classic rock’s acoustic legacy. While contemporary artists continue pushing acoustic boundaries, nothing from the last two decades cracked our top tier.

What This Says About Guitar Culture in 2025

Our poll results reveal a community that values tradition, historical knowledge, and musical depth. The fact that “Crazy on You” won so decisively shows that guitarists recognize and appreciate Nancy Wilson’s contributions to guitar literature, even if she doesn’t always get the same recognition as her male counterparts.

The strong showing for progressive rock entries like “Roundabout” and “Thick as a Brick” indicates that modern guitarists aren’t intimidated by complexity—they’re drawn to it. In an era where anyone can learn anything on YouTube, guitarists are seeking out the challenges that separate the weekend warriors from the dedicated students.

Wrapping Up: The Beat Goes On – The Greatest Acoustic Guitar Intros

This community poll proved that great acoustic guitar intros are about more than just flying through notes or familiar melodies—they’re about creating moments that stick with listeners decades after they were recorded. Nancy Wilson’s victory with “Crazy on You” reminds us that making the listener feel something to move them will always rise to the top.

Whether you’re team Heart, team Zeppelin, or still championing one of the deep cuts that grabbed a single vote, one thing’s clear: the acoustic guitar intro remains one of music’s most powerful tools for grabbing attention and creating atmosphere. These songs didn’t just win a poll—they earned their place in the pantheon by inspiring generations of players to pick up their guitars and chase that perfect opening moment.

The debate continues, the guitars keep ringing, and somewhere out there, the next legendary acoustic intro is waiting to be discovered. Until then, we’ll keep celebrating the masters who showed us how it’s done. Let us know what your fav acoustic guitar intros are in the comments below!

👉 Check out more deals and gear reviews on the Get My Guitar Blog.

👉 Join our guitarist community to share your finds and discuss all things guitar!